 | Robert Pattinson | | Connie Nikas |
| Benny Safdie | | Nick Nikas |
| Buddy Duress | | Ray |
| Taliah Webster | | Crystal |
| Jennifer Jason Leigh | | Corey Ellman |
| Barkhad Abdi | | Dash the Park Security Guard |
| Necro | | Caliph |
| Peter Verby | | Peter the Psychiatrist |
| Saida Mansoor | | Agapia Nikas |
| Gladys Mathon | | Annie |
| Rose Gregorio | | Loren Ellman |
| Eric Paykert | | Eric the Bail Bondsman |
| Astrid Corrales | | Bail Bondsman's Assistant |
| Rachel Black | | Rachel the Public Defender |
| Hirakish Ranasaki | | Trevor |
| Maynard Nicholl | | Donnie |
| Ben Edelman | | Acid Buying Complainer |
| Laurence Blum | | Nassau County Police Officer A |
| Jason Harvey | | Nassau County Police Officer B |
| Robert Clohessy | | 7th Floor Elmhurst Police Officer |
| Michael Kaufman | | EMT Worker #1 |
| Goran Spadina | | EMT Worker #2 |
| Michael McClard | | Detective |
| Eloisa Santos | | Prostitute |
| Bryan Seslow | | NYPD Investigating Officer |
| Craig muMs Grant | | Denny the Acces-A-Ride Driver |
| George Lee Miles | | Annie's Husband Albert |
| Kate Halpern | | Stringy Haired Man's Wife |
| Christopher Kirk | | Stringy Haired Man |
| Leticia Ortega | | Mexican Woman |
| Souleymane Sy Savane | | African Cab Driver |
| Mahadeo Shivraj | | Uber Driver |
| Dorothi Fox | | Elderly Woman in Hospital |
| Ratnesh Dubey | | Pizza Hut Manager |
| Tessa O'Conner | | Pizza Hut Employee |
| Jim Handley | | NYPD Officer Jim |
| Cliff Moylan | | NYPD Officer Patrick |
| Peter Linari | | Elmhurst Orderly |
| Chris Breslin | | Male Doctor |
| Evonne Walton | | Bank Teller |
