 | Piper Perabo | | Violet Sanford |
| Adam Garcia | | Kevin O'Donnell |
| John Goodman | | Bill |
| Maria Bello | | Lil |
| Izabella Miko | | Cammie |
| Tyra Banks | | Zoe |
| Bridget Moynahan | | Rachel |
| Melanie Lynskey | | Gloria |
| Del Pentecost | | Lou |
| Michael Weston | | Danny |
| LeAnn Rimes | | LeAnn Rimes |
| Jeremy Rowley | | William Morris Receptionist |
| Ellen Cleghorne | | Music Publishing Receptionist |
| John Fugelsang | | Richie the Booker |
| Bud Cort | | Romero |
| Robert Ahlers | | Finale Club Back-Up Musician |
| Orlando Sims | | Finale Club Back-Up Musician |
| Barry Michael Duff | | Finale Club Back-Up Musician |
| William Ritter III | | Finale Club Back-Up Musician |
| Chanda Bailey | | Finale Club Back-Up Musician |
| Freez Luv | | Fiji Mermaid Club Bouncer |
| Alex Band | | Fiji Mermaid Club Band |
| Miles Mosley | | Fiji Mermaid Club Band |
| Aaron Kamin | | Fiji Mermaid Club Band |
| Victor Vanacore | | Fiji Mermaid Club Band |
| Greg Pitts | | Fiji Mermaid Waiter |
| Whitney Dylan | | Fiji Mermaid Worker |
| Marvin Krueger | | Surgeon |
| Victor Argo | | Pete |
| Peter Appel | | Pizza Customer |
| John Mondin | | Pizza Customer |
| Frank Medrano | | Walt |
| Elizabeth Beckwith | | Management Office Receptionist |
| Diane Hudock | | Open Mic Woman |
| Tara MacLean | | Open Mic Singer |
| Eric Ritter | | Arlene's Grocery Audience Member |
| Thomas R. Martin | | Arlene's Grocery Audience Member |
| Ken Hudson Campbell | | Biker |
| Jorgen de Mey | | Coyote Ugly Customer |
| Jimmy Shubert | | Coyote Ugly Drunk |
